"Power is not intrinsically good or bad"

Work psychologist Petra Schmid studies the effects of social power. She favours an interdisciplinary approach that includes both lab experiments and surveys.

Woman with dusted blouse leans against a pillar of a wall.
Work psychologist Petra Schmid: «People want their work to be acknowledged and appreciated.» (Photograph: ETH Zurich / Daniel Winkler)

You study the effects of social power on human behaviour. What does that involve?
Social power is about asserting control over coveted resources. Not just money or food, but also things like affection or knowledge. Yet it’s not enough to simply have control over those resources – you only become socially powerful if someone else desires them.

Which of your findings has surprised you most?
Power was long regarded as something that sets us free, enabling us to do whatever we choose, regardless of social constraints. This gave rise to the idea that power inevitably leads people to process information rapidly and automatically and to behave in uninhibited ways. But my research has shown that people who feel powerful actually do a better job of controlling their behaviour and their cognitive processes, which is why they are more likely to achieve their goals than people who feel powerless.

Are there any situations where you feel powerless?
Whenever my work gets peer-reviewed by “Reviewer 2”! That’s the jokey term we use for the kind of arrogant, condescending peer reviewers who deploy a barrage of destructive and biased criticism when evaluating academic papers.

Do we have any control over our own social power?
You can gain social power by climbing the hierarchical ladder. But power is also a psychological state; in other words, people exhibit different feelings of power independently of their social ranking. These feelings are determined by a person’s character or mood, but are also influenced by external factors such as the situation or interaction partner.

Do people who feel powerful make better workers?
Power is not intrinsically good or bad. Those who feel powerful get less distracted and find it easier to prioritise things, which could certainly be beneficial in a work context. But my research shows that people who feel powerful are also more likely to stereotype and have prejudices against other groups.

What’s the best way to motivate employees?
Show your appreciation. People want their work to be acknowledged and appreciated.

About

Petra Schmid is Professor of Organisational Behaviour in the Department of Management, Technology and Economics at ETH Zurich.

Globe What holds the world together

Globe 23/03 Titelblatt:

This text appeared in the 23/03 issue of the ETH magazine Globe.

DownloadRead whole issue (PDF, 4.6 MB)

JavaScript has been disabled in your browser